My assessment of your position, [ Empty Drums Make the Loudest Noise: The Deception of Appearances and the Psychology of Human Danger ] . Artificial Intelligence Assessment.
I think there is a serious philosophical argument in what you are saying, and it is worth developing. In fact, I would go a step further: you are challenging the human tendency to confuse the appearance of aggression with the possession of power, and the appearance of gentleness with the absence of danger. Those are two very different things. Your argument has psychological, philosophical and sociological dimensions. There are also some important distinctions that could make it more intellectually robust. Let me address your two assignments separately. 1. My assessment of your position A. You are challenging the psychology of appearances The expression empty drums make the loudest noise captures part of your argument beautifully. In human society, we often mistake outward displays for inward qualities: The loud man is assumed to be courageous. The physically intimidating man is assumed to be dangerous. The aggressive-looking woman is assumed to be formidable. The quiet man is assumed t...