AI- the German WW2 excuse that they had no choice but to follow orders is unacceptable - feedback with accurate citations or debunk my position

 


AI Replies

The notion that German soldiers or officials "had no choice but to follow orders" during World War II, often referred to as the "Nuremberg Defense", has been a point of contention in both historical and legal analyses. 

The argument is problematic for several reasons, as historical evidence demonstrates that orders were not always followed to the death, and defiance was possible in many instances without automatic repercussions. Here are key points to evaluate this claim:

1. The Myth of Absolute Obedience

  • Hitler's "No Surrender" Orders: While Adolf Hitler issued many "no surrender" and "fight to the last man" directives, such as in Stalingrad (1942-43) and the defense of Berlin (1945), there are numerous instances where German forces disregarded these orders. For example:
    • Surrender at Stalingrad: Despite orders to hold their positions, Field Marshal Friedrich Paulus surrendered the German 6th Army in Stalingrad in February 1943. This was one of the most significant surrenders of the war, involving over 90,000 troops.
    • Western Front Surrenders: In the last months of the war, many German units, especially on the Western Front, surrendered en masse to the Allies, seeking to avoid capture by the advancing Soviet forces.
  • This undermines the idea that Germans uniformly adhered to Hitler's directives, especially when surrender appeared to be a rational alternative.


2. The Reality of Defiance

  • Examples of Resistance to Orders:
    • Many military officers and soldiers resisted committing war crimes or carrying out specific directives. For instance, General Erwin Rommel refused to execute captured Allied commandos in defiance of Hitler's infamous Kommandobefehl (Commando Order).
    • Hans von Dohnanyi and others within the Abwehr (German military intelligence) worked to subvert Nazi policies and even assisted in plots to assassinate Hitler.
  • Historical studies, such as those by historian Christopher Browning, show that individuals could and did refuse orders, particularly regarding participation in mass killings. In many cases, those who refused were not executed but reassigned.

3. Legal and Ethical Accountability

  • Post-War Trials and the Rejection of "Superior Orders":
    • The Nuremberg Trials set a precedent that "following orders" was not a sufficient defense for crimes against humanity. The tribunal emphasized that soldiers and officials had a duty to resist unlawful commands.
    • This principle is now enshrined in international law, including the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court.
  • The idea of absolute obedience fails to recognize individual agency. Even within the constraints of a dictatorship, individuals made choices that shaped the course of events.


4. The Russian Front Context

  • The German retreat from Russia highlights strategic pragmatism rather than blind adherence to Hitler's ideology:
    • Operation Barbarossa (1941) failed to achieve its goals, and subsequent Soviet counter-offensives forced German withdrawals, culminating in the loss of territories like Stalingrad and Kursk.
    • As the Soviets advanced westward, German forces surrendered in large numbers rather than fight to the death, particularly in early 1945 during the collapse of the Eastern Front.
  • These surrenders demonstrate that survival often took precedence over obedience, especially when the war's outcome was clearly unfavorable for Germany.

5. Counterarguments and Nuances

  • Fear of Retribution: It is true that Nazi Germany operated under a brutal regime where dissent could lead to severe punishment, including execution. However, this fear was not uniform, and many soldiers weighed the risks against the moral and practical implications of their actions.
  • Cultural and Institutional Indoctrination: Decades of militaristic tradition and Nazi propaganda contributed to a culture of obedience. However, evidence shows that not all Germans were equally susceptible to this indoctrination.

Conclusion

The claim that German forces "had no choice" is oversimplified and does not align with the historical record. Instances of surrender, defiance, and subversion illustrate that individual agency existed, even under the authoritarian structure of Nazi Germany. This notion is further refuted by legal precedents that stress accountability for unlawful actions, regardless of the chain of command.

Would you like more in-depth analysis on specific examples, such as Stalingrad, or a closer look at legal principles from the Nuremberg Trials?




Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Complex layers of human social behavior. Could it be that these are subconscious echoes of ancestral encounters between us modern Humans- Homo_Sapiens ALIAS '' Homo diddyoil'' and Homo_Neanderthals?

Image
  What if some of the traits we see in people from Europe, Africa, and Asia—particularly in India [ Dalits or their so called Black untouchables] —are in today's world of free education / much improved scientific chivalry and honesty from even European/ Arab/ Asian ETC scientists blatant manifestations of deeply embedded Neanderthal genetics, subconsciously influencing behavior even today? Does the intelligence of anyone who thinks this has no basis or who finds this deduction totally illogical need to be questioned, scrutinized before God, Man and Data.   One striking example is the town of Orania in South Africa, a place where racial segregation continues as you read, and Black residents are notably absent despite being in the heart of a predominantly Black continent.  Orania is in South Africa which is a country, a prominent country in Africa. While this isn't an attempt to cast blame solely on the so described and titled separately, the separatists called Oranian...
Read more

Elon Musk Is the Perfect FAKE White Man: The Epitome of FAKE White Mentality—This Is Why FAKE White People Hate Him (Beyond His Wealth). The Ancestors Sent Him to Expose the Nature They Have Killed Us for, ''FOR''... Merely Highlighting Since They Came From The Caves Of Planet Closet Nazis..

Image
For centuries, white people have built a global myth —the idea that Black men are irresponsible fathers, abandoning their children, leaving broken homes. This lie has been used to justify every racist policy imaginable, from mass incarceration to economic disenfranchisement. It has been a psychological weapon to strip Black men of dignity while upholding whiteness as the moral standard. But now, in the year 202X, the perfect white man—the whitest of them all —has arrived to shatter their carefully constructed illusion. Elon Musk, the richest man in the world, a walking monument to white entitlement, is proving that white men have always been the blueprint for reckless reproduction, strategic neglect, and the abandonment of their own blood. He has fathered at least 11 children with multiple women, scattered them across the world like colonial outposts, and yet—where is the white outrage?  Where is the global condemnation that Black men face for merely existing?  Where are the...
Read more

Supercavitation: UAV's, Whatever's Zipping Through Our Skies, Time Dilation [ Travel ] Drag Cancellation And Jump Rooms/ Jump Points Technology

Image
 Technology, Time, and Mystery: Are UFOs Hiding in Plain Physics? The world of cutting-edge technology and unexplained stuff often converge in  bat shit crazy ways, leading to provocative questions about the limits of our understanding.  Take, for instance, the principle of supercavitation, a technological grey-out used in high-speed underwater weaponry. This innovation creates a gas bubble around a projectile, drastically reducing drag and enabling astonishing speeds. Imagine applying this principle not to torpedoes slicing through water, but to unidentified flying objects (UFOs) zipping through our skies and beyond. Could similar mechanisms—on an entirely different scale—explain some of the irrational, nowadays unavoidable reported global cases of UFO sightings? Supercavitation: Redefining Speed Supercavitation technology, seen in devices like Russia’s VA-111 Shkval torpedo, shows how innovation can defy conventional limitations. By creating a "bubble" of air around an ...
Read more